"They use
their money to buy us!"
African participant, Rev. Stephen Domelevo,
Catholic Digest TV Productions / Ghana
Corridor-talk!
Another African participant declared
corridor-talk as the most interesting experience
during this conference:
Eric Chinje from Cameroon, Program Manager,
Global Media Program, The World Bank Institute.
In his power-point-presentation, Eric Chinje
summarized the "Donor Approach to Media in
Africa" as follows:
>
Evidenced outcomes do not reflect annual
investment in media development
> Media as an instrument (used when
needed; avoided when possible)
> Uncoordinated, agenda-driven,
issue-specific interventions
> Too much focus on media for
"governance &
accountability" &
ooNOT enough
on media for "improved development
outcomes"
> Absence of sector-wide solutions
> inattention to matters of
sustainibility |
Nice
observation, said corridor-talk, but where is the
World Bank Institute's initiative leading to?
According to Eric Chinje:
>
Greater coordination in all aspects of
sector support
> Holistic, multi-donor approaches
(holistic = emphasizing the
organic or functional relation between
parts and the whole)
> Engagement with Media Owners
> Support for Media Monitoring &
Audience Measurement
> Attention to Funding Mechanisms |
Eric
Chinje's overall goal, as brought forward by him
on behalf of the World Bank Institute:
...
to help to grow a coalition from
individuals and organizations in a
crowded, disconnected field ... |
In
other words: Media Development Cooperation needs
guidance, even steering; this seems to have been
the conference's major message.
But guidance and steering by whom?
No player in the field of media development
cooperation will deny that their business is
dependent on donors & sponsors without
money no media development cooperation. But, can
dependence on agendas of such donors &
sponsors be denied as well? Is it deniable that,
more and more, such agendas establish the driving
force for media development cooperation in the
Southern world?
Elsewhere on my
Internet-presentation, I picked a particular
example: Canada-based "Farm Radio
International" which supports, in its own
words, some 300 broadcasters in 39 African
countries recieves for its work financial aid
from the "Melinda & Bill
Gates-Foundation".
In RBO's "Grumbler's Corner", I forwarded the
question: " ... to what extend the
necessary debate is in safe hands with a
broadcasting organisation which receives funds
from a GMO-promoting foundation ...".
This is the background of the
Gates-GMO-initiative in Africa:
A new
Philanthro-Capitalist Alliance in Africa?
AGRA The Return of the
Green Revolution
Galés Gabirondo
2008-03-31
(http://pambazuka.org/en/category/features/47017)
(excerpt) ... Whether or not AGRA can
successfully bring the new Green Revolution to
Africa, and whether or not the Green Revolution
will benefit the poor as much as it benefits the
capitalists being courted by the Gates Foundation
are two different questions that should be open
to public debate. Unfortunately, there was never
a public debate on AGRA.
There are many productive agroecological farming
systems in Africa that do not depend on GMOs or
other Green Revolution technologies, but these
alternatives were never considered. Whether or
not AGRA can re-start the Green Revolution in
Africa is yet to be seen. What is clear thus far
is that it has been successful in eliminating
competition for the control of African food
systems.
AGRAs philanthro-capitalism draws the
worlds attention away from local
alternatives and towards global market-based
solutions that ultimately favor those
with more international market power, i.e., the
seed and chemical monopolies. Though it
strengthens corporate opportunities and power, it
does nothing to address the weakened ministerial
and regulatory capacity of the state, ignores the
need to protect local markets or ensure a greater
market share of the value chain for farmers. It
elides land issues and does not address the
eroding economic and environmental resiliency of
African food systems. Worse, it diverts attention
away from the role that the global markets play
in creating hunger and poverty in Africa in the
first place. Can AGRA actually solve these
problems? Not without addressing their causes.
So, why was
it for the corridor-talk not a
surprise to be introduced on Schloss Eichholz to
the World Bank supported "Media Map
Project" which tries to measure "the
impact of media development worldwide".
However, their worldwide view seems somehow
limited to Southern countries which stand for
Northern anti-terror-worries: Pakistan,
Afghanistan, Azerbaijan ...
And then, it was almost escaping the
corridor-talk's attention: Major-sponsor of the
mapping-project is?
Yes, the "Melinda & Bill
Gates-Foundation"!
see also: THE ISSUE AT HAND
... und auf
Deutsch: Bertelsmanns
journalistischer Brückenkopf, oder: Was
afrikanische Journalisten wirklich brauchen
REACTIONS & VIEWPOINTS
|
|
11.11.2010
Interessanter Rückblick von Simon
Haslock, Albany Associates:
"Writing in a special report for the
United States Institute of Peace, Simon
Haselock, co-founder of Albany
Associates, charts the results of taking
a grassroots approach to
communications in conflicts around the
world. Drawing conclusions for today's
mission in Afghanistan, he identifies
political and peacemaking achievements
over the past two decades in Bosnia,
Kosovo, Iraq and Darfur borne out of
local participation, strong media
regulation and the process of
"letting go" by the
international community.!
"Make it theirs: the imperative of
local ownership in communications and
media initiatives" is attached and
can be found at: www.usip.org/publications/make-it-theirs
Gruss,
Klaas Glenewinkel
media in cooperation & transition
Klaas Glenewinkel, Managing Director
klaas@mict-international.org
mobile ++49 151 504 234 55
mict gGmbH, brunnenstrasse 9 / 10119
berlin / germany
phone ++49 30 484 9302 16 / fax ++49 30
690 88 390
www.mict-international.org
09.11.2010
Flirting with fiction
In the BBC-series
of viewpoints from African journalists,
filmmaker and columnist Farai Sevenzo
considers African story-telling and the
reporting of the continent in an age of
cuts.
"... Our reportage has been taken
over by the humanitarians, by the United
Nations missions, by the star journalists
flying in from London or Washington or
Doha on reporting holidays; and the
stories that we may want to hear, can now
be found by word of mouth only ..." http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-11719993
|
|